Four Problems with Technical Analysis
Being a geek, it's only natural that I'm primarily a technical trader. However, I've never been satisfied with the current state of Technical Analysis (TA) because of the lack of a widespread, rigorous scientific approach to the subject. Here are four main problems with technical analysis that I see: 1. Classic chart-reading is too subjective: "It's a rising wedge of course!"
"Err, and it has a head and shoulders top kind of embedded in it...or something."
"Actually, I think it's an uptrend with a channel line, which is just part of a larger diamond consolidation formation..." Yeah, right. The problem here is that human beings tend to look for patterns, so the more patterns that chartists "define", the more likely it is that one or more of them will show up in a chart. There's no confirmed uptrend on the chart? What about a reverse head & shoulders? No? OK, well how about a rising wedge or a falling flag, or maybe a cup with handle, rounded bottom, or double top? Get the idea? If you can't find a pattern, just keep inventing new patterns until one shows up on your charts. This isn't helpful, and the problem is exacerbated by the fact that most of the "patterns" in classic chart reading are not rigorously defined. By this I mean that it would be difficult to write a computer algorithm that describes how to identify every possible instance of the pattern. One of the major research projects that I've worked on over the past couple of years involves a method of classifying and identifying chart patterns in a rigorous way. This method, called "Bar Pattern Analysis" (BPA), consists of coding certain characteristics of price behavior so that any action on a chart has a unique "string" of code that describes it. This way, there is never any doubt about what pattern we are looking at, keeping everyone on the same sheet of music. I'm still working through some conceptual issues with this approach, and will write more about it in future articles. 2. Few TA indicator "signals" are supported by research: Technical Analysis does not just consist of classic chart reading however. Many technicians understood the drawbacks of classic chart patterns that I've discussed, and took a great step forward with the construction of indicators. Technical indicators such as moving averages, MACD and RSI provide clear unambiguous signals such as moving average crossovers, overbought/oversold levels and so forth and helped to eliminate much of the "subjectivity problem" with TA. However, not everyone agrees whether a given signal is bullish or bearish. Even when there is agreement, it is usually based only on common beliefs about market behavior or on anecdotal evidence ("See? The Williams %R flashed an oversold signal on GBP/USD here, and the price went up soon after!"). This is not to say that no actual scientific research has been done on TA indicators, but it's far from a common practice. Much of my own work involves the use of statistical analysis to determine whether the behavior of a given technical signal has any significant correlation to future price movements. 3. Technical Analysis deals mainly with direction: There are certain chart patterns like triangles and flags which are supposed to tell you not only the direction of a future price move, but also how far the price will move. However, most of TA just answers the question "up or down?" That's not enough. When I traded currencies in 2004, I was constantly setting my stops too tight, my targets too far away, or vice-versa. This experience made me realize that "up or down" is not the only important information. Traders need answers to questions like "Should I set a tight stop or a wide stop in this situation?" and "Should I set my price target close for a small but likely profit, or far away for a larger but less likely gain?" In my research into FOREX price behavior, I try to design my research efforts to include not only the question of which way, but the question of how far as well. 4. The effectiveness of indicators changes as market behavior changes: This is a conjectural model of how markets work that I'm studying currently. By "conjectural model" I simply mean that this theory makes logical sense, but I don't have a shred of evidence to support it yet. The general idea is that the makeup of the "crowd" that is currently involved in actively trading a financial instrument changes over time as some people cease trading it and others begin trading it. Each individual trader has their own style, and as the makeup of the "crowd" changes gradually over time, the behavior of the price will change its characteristics as well. I suspect that this is an evolutionary process rather than a revolutionary one. For any given period of time though, the price behavior will have a certain "personality", a phenomenon that I've seen mentioned by many traders. Consequently, I believe that there are actually no "good" or "bad" indicators. There are just indicators which are currently working well for a given market and others which are not. One of the constant challenges for traders is to determine which is which, and to update their trading strategies accordingly. Some of my current research centers around creating tools which allow traders to do this. Instead of a trader saying, "Well I use a combination of moving averages and RSI" and so on, my vision is that traders will be able to say, "I use whatever indicators happen to be working best right now in whichever market I'm trading." Scott Percival
October 2006 Scott Percival is the Director of Research for the FOREX Statistical Research Center at Market-geeks.com, a site which is devoted to using mathematics and the scientific method to study the behavior of prices in the FOREX market. Mr. Percival has a degree in Civil Engineering from Northeastern University, and has worked as a Registered Representative and trading instructor at Fidelity Investments. He is currently working toward the goal of becoming a full time FOREX trader. Market-geeks.com
Now...you have the edge. |
Other Currency Trading Articles
Why Choose Forex Trading Over Stocks Trading Forex trading holds significant differences to stocks trading. Understanding these differences will aid a trader in deciding the right market to enter. Forex trading itself has several advantages over stocks trading and is ideal for the beginner and individual small investors.1. Low Transaction Costs for Forex Trading. There are no h ...A Mini-Guide To The Managed Forex Account A managed forex account is forex made easy. It is especially tailored for those investors who do not have the time or desire to monitor their own forex account. Many different companies offer these accounts to their clients. A managed forex account is often chosen by individuals who wish to take advantage of the high liquidity and high profit ...A Comprehensive Forex Broker Register A comprehensive forex broker list includes investment banks with dealing rooms, commercial banks with treasury operations, and online brokerages that serve a larger market. The investment banks with forex trading capabilities include Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch, Goldman Sachs, Salomon Smith Barney, Lehman Brothers, Credit Suisse First Boston, ...Should You Join an Online Stock Trading Forum? If you're involved in online stock trading then you know how important it is to have timely and quality information. From experience the best way to get this information is to become a member of a good online stock trading forum.Benefits:In any business it's good to be able to discuss things with others in the same field, and if no ...Choosing the Right Forex Broker If you've already made the decision to go ahead and start trading forex, the first step you need to take is to choose the right forex broker. Currency brokers vary more than the U.S. Investment houses, so you really need to do your homework before making a decision. This is very important because your broker is almost like your business partne ...Big profits from Currency Trading If you want to make big profits from currency trading, you need to lock into and follow the longer-term trends.“The art of contrary” thinking is one of the most powerful tools a trader can use, and is a trait with which all true great traders are familiar with.What is the Art of Contrary Thinking?Humphrey Neill’s book, "the ...Beginner Traders Information on Futures Index Trading Futures IndexesIn 1982 the Chicago Mercantile Exchange brought out the S&P 500 and the life of an index trader was possible. You could buy or sell the equivalent of the 500 largest capitalization stocks in the country, stocks on the New York Stock Exchange, on the American Stock Exchange, on the Nasdaq stock exchange all in one ind ...How to Protect Yourself Against a Falling U.S. Dollar If you use U.S. dollars in large quantities either as an American living in the U.S., or if you are a businessman that lives outside of the U.S but pays vendors in U.S. dollars, or if you are an American expat living overseas crying buckets everyday as the dollar buys less and less of the foreign currency of the country you are living in, then t ...Candlestick Charting – Adding a Visual Dimension To Your Trading Candlestick charting is great for traders wanting an extra edge in their quest for profits - this is due to the way the candle bodies are drawn, that gives a better insight that is visual, and shows trader psychology.More traders than ever are using candlestick charts due to the extra trading edge they can get with this form of charting - ...Currency Trading – 5 Steps To Trading Success Currency trading is all about trading the right way to achieve currency trading success. It’s a blend of various inputs that will make you successful. Get just one of them wrong and you will lose.This article is for both novice traders who have never traded before and seasoned traders who want to achieve greater profits.Here are th ...Currency Trading is Not the Monopoly of the Nerds and the Geeks The general perception is that any and every person who is involved in the business of trading of currency or foreign exchange is a person who has a super high IQ. To hear words and phrases like liquidity ratio, central bank intervention and inflationary demand makes us feel as if we are back in the boring and inherently avoidable lecture on eco ...Savvy Tactics to Minimize Whopping Forex Losses Forex trading has one goal: to make money. Unfortunately, like any speculative venture, there is a potential for loosing money. The same holds true with the stock market the commodities market, and the money market. Any investment that entices of great gain poses a certain level of risk. As a forex trader you want to minimize your chance ...Forex Trading: Calculating Profit and Loss in Foreign Currency Trading The foreign exchange market, or Forex market, is an around-the-clock cash market where the currencies of nations are bought and sold. Forex trading is always done in currency pairs. For example, you buy Euros, paying with U.S. Dollars, or you sell Canadian Dollars for Japanese Yen. The value of your Forex investment increases or decreases becaus ...Trading Vehicles The best Trading Vehicles have two characteristics that are paramount: Price and Liquidity.If you're trading stocks, look for good liquid trading markets that are tight and fluid.Bid and Ask quotes are narrow and close to the last trade. The quotes have depth to them and can accommodate large orders without disturbing the price. ...Winning at Commodity Trading Commodity Exchanges offer the facilities for the organized marketing of most commodities. These include grain, wheat, cocoa, sugar, soya beans, wool and livestock. It also includes metals and minerals, such as gold, silver, copper and tin.The rationale behind this marketplace is to allow commodity producers to sell their produce in adv ...Forex Trading Education Foreign Exchange (FOREX) Trading is the concurrent buying and trading of different currencies. The industry is very fast paced with sudden changes happening everyday. There are a lot of factors that affect the market value of each currency, a lot of analysis and computation involved to try to make accurate predictions of the next direction the m ...Commodity Futures Trading Unlike cash contracts, which require the payment of cash against the physical delivery of goods immediately or after a specified period, a futures contract is a special type of agreement made strictly under the rules of a commodity exchange, which may or may not call for the actual delivery of goods and payment of price in cash on a future date. ...Learn FOREX The foreign exchange market, also knows as FOREX, originated in 1973 has become the largest e-currency trade market in the world today. FOREX trading occurs 24 hours a day, 5 days a week. The FOREX market offers a unique trading opportunity to those seeking a substantial profit in a market that trades over 1.2 trillion dollars each day.FO ...Commodity Trading - Advantages and Disadvantages What Is Commodity Trading?Commodity futures markets allow commercial producers and commercial consumers to offset the risk of adverse future price movements in the commodities that they are selling or buying.In order to work a futures contract must be standardised. They must have a standard size and grade, expire on a certai ...How Do Other Countries Devalue Their Currencies? Countries devalue their currencies only when they have no other way to correct past economic mistakes - whether their own or mistakes committed by their predecessors.The ills of a devaluation are still at least equal to its advantages.True, it does encourage exports and discourage imports to some extents and for a limited period of ...Introduction To Fundamental Analysis: Forex FOREX traders almost always rely on analysis to make plan their trading strategies. There are two basic types of FOREX analysis – technical and fundamental. This article will look at fundamental analysis and how it used in FOREX trading.Fundamental analysis refers to political and economic conditions that may affect currency prices. FOREX ...Day Trading Day traders are people who buy and sell stocks all day long. The goal of a day trader is to buy stocks that fluctuate in hopes that the value goes up and the trader earns money Day traders can make profits very quickly. A day trader will hold a stock anywhere from a few seconds to a few hours, but will always sell all stocks before the close of ...Currency Trading Psychology - Controlling your Emotions The fact is, the majority of traders lose because they cannot control their emotions - and their emotions cause them to make irrational trades and lose.Trading psychology is one of the keys to investment success, but its impact is not understood by many investors, who simply think they need a good trading method, but this is only part of ...Ten Tips for Successful Currency Trading Here are 10 tips for successful currency trading, and if you can implement them in your trading plan, your chances of trading success will be greatly enhanced.1. Desire to Succeed - All the great traders have a burning desire to succeed and will do whatever is necessary to succeed.2. Work Smart, not Hard - The amount of effort you ...Stocks Or Foreign Exchange - Which One? Many people would like to invest in stocks or Forex but are not really sure of the difference between the two and don’t know which is the right choice for them. There is little doubt that there are many options out there for you. But, it is hard to say which the right choice is until you gather some information about them and then make the righ ...E-currency Exchange Training Programs Reviewed Many people are asking about the e-currency trading course. When thinking of e-currency trading, people tend to think of the FOREX market. What people need to know is that we are not talking about FOREX here, rather a system that allows people to act as a middle man and process transactions from one e-currency to another. For example, moving ...Forex Strategy: How The MACD Indicator Can Save You Anxiety The MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence) indicator can add a degree of certainty to your Forex strategy.As with any indicator, it is too risky to enter trades on this signal alone. However, as we will see, used with caution on higher time frames, it can help confirm you are going in the right direction and that your trade is highe ...
|
