Mechanical or Discretionary Trading - Which is Best?
Discretionary Trading Pure discretionary trading will rely solely on the traders judgement. For example a discretionary trader may spot a particular pattern developing on a chart and decide to enter a trade on that basis. It would be impossible to systemise their trading because it relies on subjective judgements and 'gut' feel. Mechanical Trading Pure mechanical trading involves the development of trading rules that cover every situation, from entry to exit and position sizing. The trader is executing a predefined plan. They must however take every trade that the system gives them which can be difficult if the trader begins to 'think' too much! Both sets of trader are working hard at different times and at different things. The mechanical trader spends time developing a system and does not need to think whilst trading, merely executing a plan. The discretionary trader has to be thinking all the time that they are trading and can suffer from 'information overload'. Which is best? The answer is probably a combination of both approaches. Coming to the market with a proven strategy rather than relying on gut instinct is far less stressful and gives the trader more confidence. However the markets are always changing and one trading strategy will not work forever - i.e. the Turtle Traders. Strategies will always need updating. Many traders will use a mechanical system to generate buy and sell signals but then use discretion, reading the market, to attempt to gain better fill prices. All successful traders will use some sort of proven trading strategy to begin with but the level of discretion allowed by it will vary. A trader with no plan at all will fail. Tim Wreford runs Online Futures Trading, a website that provides information and resources for traders. Tim also provides a free day trading system, the results of which are updated daily on the site. |
Other Currency Trading Articles
Currency Trading Seminars – The Best Way To Learn and They Can Be FREE The best way to learn to trade currencies is to attend a currency trading seminar, as you will gain a far greater insight into trading than by simply reading books.Many currency trading seminars not only allow you to learn theory, but also to apply what you have learned in practice in real trading situations, so you can test what you have ...Choosing the Right Forex Broker If you've already made the decision to go ahead and start trading forex, the first step you need to take is to choose the right forex broker. Currency brokers vary more than the U.S. Investment houses, so you really need to do your homework before making a decision. This is very important because your broker is almost like your business partne ...The Day Forex Guide to Profitable Trading Do you want to make larger and easier profits with your online day trading? Are you looking for a day forex guide to profitable trading of stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and currency online? Here are my top 3 hints to day trading profits.Hint #1 – Balance your portfolioYou have to maintain a strong balance between long term investm ...New Opportunities with Forex Trading The simplest definition of currency trading is the practice of exchanging one country's currency for another country's currency. Basically, currency trading involves four main variables: currencies, exchange rate, time, and interest rate. The interplay of these variables creates opportunities for small investors to obtain investment returns that ...Winning at Commodity Trading Commodity Exchanges offer the facilities for the organized marketing of most commodities. These include grain, wheat, cocoa, sugar, soya beans, wool and livestock. It also includes metals and minerals, such as gold, silver, copper and tin.The rationale behind this marketplace is to allow commodity producers to sell their produce in adv ...Chinese Yen and Inflation Dangers A surge in a Yen could be problematic at this point and yet they have been playing their currency too long. Other nations have been very upset with the currency manipulation up until now. Are they allowing this increased strength right now prior to the World Bank and G-7 meeting to appease the World and their trading partners or are they doing i ...Making Money In Forex Trading Fact or Fiction? Find out the real truth about making money in forex trading.Recently theres been a surge of everyday, average investors choosing to invest the majority of their portfolio in forex trading. If you talk with those people, you'll find many feel making money in forex trading is much easier than using more traditional types of investing. ...Stock Day Trading In order to trade stocks during the day, you need to know what to look for in the stocks you are buying or selling. The attributes that you should be concerned with are liquidity, volume, volatility and price transparency.Liquidity is important to a trader who requires fast executions a predictable prices, It is based on factors such as t ...Trading The Market: Keep It Simple Stupid! It seems like each day there is another complicated trading system in development. I am quite surprised to see the trading population dig into more complex methods combining various indicators to profit from the financial markets. How many confirmations does one need? By the time all your indicators confirm a buy or sell signal, your entry point ...How To Really Start Making Money With FOREX Trading If you've been checking out ways to get started in investing, chances are you've heard about the foreign exchange market, or FOREX trading. If you're unfamiliar with this type of trading, it can all seem a bit too hard, but in fact the hardest part is getting started. Keep reading to find out the basics of FOREX trading and what you need to do ...Forex2u Forex Strategy On Successful Forex Trading The essence of the FX2u Forex strategy is that it does not have any Forex trading system but could forecast the market trend accurately.Every set of Forex trading system available has its disadvantages. The market trend could not be forecasted. If the market could be forecasted, by depending on the RSI, PAR, MOM analysis techniques and so ...Poor Man's Access To Foreign Currency Trading By far, the largest trading market in the world is the foreign currency market. Speculators make up only a small part of the spot (cash market) and forward (futures market) currency exchange transactions. So if you are considering speculating in this area, be aware that you are trying to out-guess the brightest minds & supercomputers at large ba ...Five Reasons You Have to Start Forex Trading Why should you consider foreign exchange, or forex trading? One compelling reason is that it is a huge business, trading nearly two trillion U.S. dollars on a daily basis. The potential to make money is out there for the well-informed trader. The forex market is the largest in the world. It is larger than the U.S. stock market, and has a daily t ...Bollinger Bands – How to Use Them to Make Massive Profits Bollinger bands will help you to predict big trending moves, act on big trend reversals and finally, time trading positions with greater accuracy for bigger profits.Here we have related Bollinger bands to the currency markets (as it is here that they are most useful) - but they are useful in all financial markets.What are Bollinger ...Day Trading Securities - How To Make Money Day Trading Online What is day trading?Day trading is an extremely risky way of investing in the stock market. Day trading is carried out by day traders who rapidly purchase and sell stocks over a single day period in the hope that for the very short period over which they hold the stocks (ranging from just a few seconds to a couple of hours) the value will ...Predicting the Market Using Gann Angles - An Alternative Slant on Market Timing W D Gann was a prolific writer and trader, and created a fortune of over 50 million dollars (equivalent to 500 million today!).Many of his trading predictions were the subject of public record. For instance, he correctly predicted the 1929 crash a year in advance!Gann died in 1955, but he still holds legendary status as a technical ...Forex Research - Some Tips To Help Make The Right Choice With two trillion in trades every day in the Forex market, yet with only five percent making huge profits, this seems to indicate not very many people are depending on Forex research to make their trading decisions. This is because most people tend to make their trading decisions based on instinct and intuition instead of Forex research. If they ...Two Great Forex Indicators: Bollinger Bands and Fibonacci Retracements Forex trading is a fascinating way of earning a living online, and if you are seriously considering entering this fascinating world of forex trading you must consider, by all means, the learning and understanding of a number of indicators that will give you invaluable help on predicting with a high probability the directions the forex market may ...Day Trading Tips Worth Reading Are you tired of the same old day trading tips? Like, “cut your losses and let your profits run.” “Never let a gain turn into a loss.”, or the most repeated tip, “Buy low, sell high.”So how about something new? Let me give you some specific day trading tips that will turn your trading around.A good defense beats a ...W D Gann - How to Use His Unique Methods to Make Big Trading Profits In the entrance to the New York Stock Exchange, stands a life-sized picture of W D. Gann (1878 - 1955) and this is a testament to his standing amongst traders worldwide. Today he remains one of the most influential traders of all time.W D Gann Methods and Trading PerformanceW D Gann employed a staff of 25 draughtsmen to draw charts ...Learn Forex Trading and Multiply Your Wealth To many people that sounds amazing, and perhaps it is. It can be very profitable for investors and fortunes have been made by many. The incentive to learn forex trading is the oldest incentive by far, the incentive to make profit. If you learn forex trading you are learning how to make your money make more money for you, the goal of all inves ...Utilise Online Resources To Help You Become A Successful Forex Trader As with almost anything concerned with making money, searching the Internet for Forex will give you a wealth of information. Some of this information can be very useful while some of it very dubious in nature. Be sure not to pay over the odds for a training course or trading software. Many sites offer a very convincing case for you to spend seve ...E-currency Trading - An Alternative to Futures & Forex Trading I find it amazing that nearly everyday I receive something online or offline that is the greatest break-through in Trading. You know the stuff. This ‘system´ or that ‘method´ has been thoroughly tested and back-tested in every conceivable fashion and is wildly successful. Some work for a period of time but most do not. The decades old statistica ...Trading Discipline - Do You Have It ? dis ci pline (n.) 1. Training intended to produce a specified character or pattern of behavior. 2. Controlled behavior resulting from such training. 3. A state of order based upon submission to rules and authority. WEBSTER'S CONCISE DICTIONARY.How do you react to rules? Do you find them to be a burden, a drudgery to observe and obey? Do y ...A Forex Trader's Biggest Enemy The biggest enemy to most forex traders is not the market or their trading system but the use of leverage. When using too much of it, most of times it will take your account serious down, even with one single trade.Last week, a new forex trader showed us his account statement and asked what he was doing wrong. After taking ...FOREX Trading Strategy - The Secret of Timing Once you’ve identified a trading opportunity, the next step is to decide EXACTLY when to buy - and this is where many traders go wrong.Here we explain how to incorporate better market timing into your FOREX strategy - so that you can make bigger profits.Most traders time their entry levels incorrectly, so here’s the right way to do ...Forex Profits The Forex Market—What, When and Why?Forex, FX and the Forex market are some common abbreviations for the Foreign Exchange market. Actually it is the largest financial market in the world, where money is sold and bought freely. In its present condition the Forex market was launched in the seventies, when free exchange rates were introduced ...Stocks and Shares Trading Scams Have you seen an offer for stocks and shares trading software that seems to be too good to be true? Chances are you're absolutely right!Like most promotions that promise the easy life, with you sitting back after an hour or so at work in your pyjamas while the dollars come rolling in, it's probably another scam. Share trading scams are m ...Forex Exchange Rate - How Does It Get Calculated? In the Forex market the value of two separate currencies and how they relate to one another is what is known as the Forex exchange rate. Usually the Forex rate is how much of one currency is needed to buy a unit of another. Knowing the basics regarding the Forex exchange can help you get started in understanding it even better.Just to giv ...High Return Investments – Why the Majority of Traders Don't Win! Lets face it, we all want high return investments but the majority of investors achieve mediocre returns and this is they don’t understand two important facts.If they did, they could be on their way to far higher returns And a true high yield investment.Let’s look at the above in more detail and two keys to making huge returns from ...Beginner Day Traders - Easy Money? In day trading you are pitting your wits against every other person in the market. Every dollar you make is on the back of someone else's losses.Every losing trader has failed at trading. Every successful trader has also failed at trading in their past.It is a very rare individual that can make money off capital loaned - the psycho ...Trading Forex Currency Trade is basically defined as an exchange of goods or services at an agreed rate of exchange (e.g. two apples for three oranges). And in the same way that apples and bananas can be traded, currencies can also be exchanged for one another.Foreign Exchange or Forex currency trading involves buying and selling one currency for another at a ...Currency Options - 3 Secrets Of Options Trading For Huge Gains! Many traders love the idea of currency options, they have unlimited gains and limited risk – sounds great in theory, but in practice 90% expire worthless!This article is all about how the pros use currency options to generate big consistent gains and how the losing majority don’t understand the odds of success.This article will giv ...How to Learn Electronic Currency Exchanging If you haven't heard of the possibilities of what is possible when you get started with E-currency Trading, then this article is for you. We are going to explore the benefits you can get by getting started in this business.Is it true that you can make money with Electronic Currency Exchanging? How can we be clear on this to understand eac ...The Biggest Secret to Successful Currency Trading Successful currency trading looks deceptively simple, yet few traders succeed - despite the fact that there is plenty of material around to show them how. So why is this? - The fact is, much of the conventional wisdom given about successful currency trading, actually leads to the opposite - it actually causes traders to fail.So, let’s loo ...The Foreign Exchange Future Market: A Good Mechanism First things first, what is a Foreign Exchange Market for futures contract. In the United States, this type of contract basically means that it is an agreement wherein both parties agree to buy and/or sell a particular currency (not the USD) at a specified price on a specified date in the future, as according to a standard contract that is agre ...
|
