What is Expectancy?
I have been watching as a several people on a forum discuss, argue and lend their ideas about entry techniques. They are going crazy over what the proper entry should be and why one chart pattern is better than the other. One person has even said how they purchased massive amounts of software to help them enter the market. Now don’t get me wrong, I always use techniques to get me in the market but I understand that this is the least important factor weighing on an investor’s overall success. I use technical analysis every day and I study patterns that allow me to enter with the ideal buy point (what I believe to be the ideal entry) but I know that strong up-trending stocks give me just as good a chance to make money as stocks breaking out of a cup with handle pattern. I am one that makes my living buying stocks making new highs so I can basically prove that the random entry strategy does work as long as strong money management and exit strategies exists. By reviewing my personal trades and the coverage of dozens of stocks on the MSW Index over the past two years, I can tell you that my system with the highest expectancy is buying fundamentally sound stocks that are making new highs on above average volume. Where do I find these fundamentally sound stocks? I use multiple computerized screeners that filter out stocks with increasing earnings, high EPS ratings and increasing relative strength ratings. Once I find these stocks, I narrow them down using my own eyes by performing technical analysis. The process is simple as I am basically looking for stocks making new highs with decent to strong fundamental numbers. The process is almost random. To tell you the truth, I could probably narrow down my buy candidates each week to a list of 20 and throw darts at ten stocks to buy the following week and still have a profitable year because I do use position sizing and strict sell rules. Think I am crazy: think again as I explain what expectancy is. I responded on the forum by saying: Entering at the right time is important and it can lower your risk and increase your overall expectancy but money management and exits are much more important than entry. Studies have been done between random entry systems and specific systems that use entries based off of chart patterns with amazing results. The random entry system typically outperforms the structured entry system when it uses money management (position sizing techniques) and a strong exit strategy (assuming that the structured system doesn’t employ money management tools). I love CANSLIM and O’Neil but the entry is not the most important aspect you should be focusing on, it is money management and exits. Most people don’t want to hear this and that is why so many “entry based systems” sell so well over the years. How many of those systems actually make their users money? CANSLIM does use a 7%-10% sell stop rule but it ignores position sizing and never explains the probabilities of the system when implemented in certain ways. As I said, I make money using a system based from CANSLIM (an entry system) but it is heavily balanced with strong money management techniques and a strong exit strategy. So what is expectancy? Expectancy tells you what you can expect to make (win or lose) for every dollar risked. Casinos make money because the expectancy of every one of their games is in their favor. Play long enough and you are expected to lose and they are expected to win because the “odds” are in their favor. Most games at a casino are completed in a short period of time so they can increase their odds of winning. The same holds true for investing. If your expectancy is positive; you can make more money with multiple trades in shorter periods of time. If you told me this ten years ago, I would strongly disagree based solely on beliefs. Now with experience, I continue to move down the path to more frequent trading and a structured system that is run like a business. I now have massive amounts of data based on real trading that I have performed over the past several years. Expectancy is your profit percentage per win multiplied by your win rate minus your loss percentage per loss multiplied by your loss rate. I will use examples from Trader Mike’s: Trading 101: Expectancy (tradermike.net) and Van Tharp's Book: Trade your way to Financial Freedom: Expectancy = (Probability of Win * Average Win) - (Probability of Loss * Average Loss) Expectancy = (PW*AW) less (PL*AL)
PW is the probability of winning and PL is the probability of losing.
AW is the average gain (win) and AL is the average loss So let’s do an example (assume $12,500 per position, a $100,000 portfolio using 1% equity risk):
If my trades are successful 40% of the time and I realize an average profit of 20% but I lose an average of 5%, my expectancy is $625 per trade. (0.4 * $3,125) - (0.6 * $625) = $625 $1,250-$375 = $625 I lose 60% of the time yet I show a profit of $625 per trade. If I have a system that produces 65 trades per year, I would realize an annual gain of $40,625 (hypothetical scenario). A 40% gain on the original $100,000 (minus all commissions, fees, taxes and compounding). Trader Mike (tradermike.net) offers an example geared towards a day trader: "As an example let's say that a trader has a system that produces winning trades 30% of the time. That trader's average winning trade nets 10% while losing trades lose 3%. So if he were trading $10,000 positions his expectancy would be:
(0.3 * $1,000) - (0.7 * $300) = $90 So even though that system produces losing trades 70% of the time the expectancy is still positive and thus the trader can make money over time. You can also see how you could have a system that produces winning trades the majority of the time but would have a negative expectancy if the average loss was larger than the average win:
(0.6 * $400) - (0.4 * $650) = -$20 In fact, you could come up with any number of scenarios that would give you a positive, or negative, expectancy. The interesting thing is that most of us would feel better with a system that produced more winning trades than losers. The vast majority of people would have a lot of trouble with the first system above because of our natural tendency to want to be right all of the time. Yet we can see just by those two examples that the percentage of winning trades is not the most important factor in building a system. "
- Trader Mike Most traders look for three major factors when developing a system:
The right odds or positive expectancy
Multiple trades (opportunity)
Shorter holding periods to compound the profits Let’s look at the calculation one more time using only percentages:
PW: 48%
AW: 10%
PL: 52%
AL: 4% (48% * 10%) - (52% * 4%) = 2.72% Using a trade size of $12,500, each trade would return you $340 or 2.72% (profit). Let’s say this system gives you 200 trades per year; your result would be a $68,000 profit with only 1% of equity risked or $12,500 on $100,000. This doesn’t include compounding profits with each successful trade. A positive expectancy can come from an unlimited amount of numbers or scenarios. You could have a system that produces winners 30%, 50% or 80% of the time and each system could be positive or negative based on PW, AW, PL & AL. An infinite number of trading systems and/or number combinations can be used to find a positive expectancy system. The one thing I have realized over the past few years as my account grows is the fact that opportunity must exist to make money with a positive expectancy system. Think of the casino; the more you play, they more they win. The same is true for trading; the more you play with a positive expectancy system, the more your odds are for that system to return the expected number. I have been tailoring my system to produce more trades and opportunity so I can take full advantage of the mathematical odds. As many of you know, I graduated as an architectural engineer and love numbers since my courses were based in advanced math and physics. Numbers don’t lie; I love to play poker because I understand the odds so I am typically successful over long stretches of time at the table because I have the emotional stability to only jam the pot when the odds are in my favor. Like stocks, I do my best to let go of losing hands and losing positions (sometimes I follow a committed hand in poker or a committed position with stocks but the odds are no longer in my favor and more times than not, I lose the hand or settle for my maximum stop). I am attracted to games with numbers and odds and the stock market is the best game in the world (in my opinion). Poker is a close second. I want you to think about one more example (provided from ARB Trading - www.arbtrading.com) "You will be more profitable with $100,000 that you could "turn" 250 times per year, than $500,000 that was tied up in one trade for 12 months. As an example, let's say we have one trade and that trade yielded a 50% return. You just had a great year - a $250,000 profit. On the other hand, say you had $100,000 for stock purchases, and your expectancy was only 1.2% per trade but you turned over your stocks 250 times in the same year. This method ends up generating $300,000 for the year, and that assumes you never increase the position size as the equity grows. You just had a better year. And it is easier to get 1.2% per trade than 50%." - ARB Trading Chris Perruna - http://www.marketstockwatch.com Market Talk with Piranha Chris is the founder and president of http://www.marketstockwatch.com an internet community that teaches you how to invest your money with solid rules. We offer an extended no obligation monthly trial period starting immediately with two free weeks. We don't stop at just showing you our daily and weekly screens, we teach you how to make you own screens through education. Through our philosophy, you will be able to create your own methods and styles to become successful. |
Other Trading System Articles
An Insider's Look On The Mazu Business Pack Have you herd about the mazu business pack? If you are reading this article I am sure you know a little bit about it. If not I am going to tell you exactly what comes with the mazu business pack, and why it is one of the top home business programs on the Internet.If you are someone that is looking to work at home, and are tired of ...Trading Forex with Pivot Points Pivot Points are calculated on the previous days move and trades are entered when the market hits a support or resistance line of the pivot point providing your OB/OS indicator is in agreement. All the support and resist lines are put in place 1st thing in the morning. then you wait for the market to hit those entry Points.Contrary to wha ...What Are the Hidden Odds of Trading Anyone who is vaguely familiar with gambling knows that the house has the odds in their favor. Do some people leave a casino with large winnings? Yes, but that's because they left before they lost it back to the casino. If they had won and then continued to play long enough it is a mathematical certainty that would lose all of it back to the hou ...The Rubber Band Forex Trading System Of the many trading methods available out there there is one that has been recently realized and that is amazingly simple and uses the forex trading platform of your choice. This trading method will show you how to build your own indicator suite based on the author's recommendation, but this method is not only colored screenshots, it will allow ...Forex Day Trading Tips You Need to Know The popularity of forex currency trading system continues to grow as more and more people have realized the potential income that they can earn from forex trading.With a massive daily profit of $1.5 trillion, forex trading has definitely surpassed the combined profits of bond market and global stock market. This is probably the main reaso ...Day Trading the Emini - Training Ground For Big Contracts In 1997 the Chicago Mercantile Exchange created a new financial instrument known as the emini futures contract. It started off small but now is a fully mature market with excellent liquidity.Now in 2005, the emini futures contract is an investment vehicle of choice, for beginning and experienced futures traders the world ...Effective Forex Trading for Beginners Foreign exchange trading is gradually becoming an activity for men and women seeking financial freedom without the hassles of a conventional job or the headache and disappointment that comes with Internet marketing. The most appealing part of this business is the financial freedom it promises with very minimal effort, once the initial efforts i ...Revealed - Million Dollar Forex Investing Mistakes Anytime that you are investing in the Forex market, you are going into the Market blind. You don’t know what point of the investing trend you are entering in at. You might be investing in a Forex stock just before the trend changes. Smart investing means you need to protect your trading float and set up a stop loss. This needs to be done before ...Discount Online Futures Trading Futures are contracts that obligate sellers to provide buyers a commodity or other asset at an agreed-upon price and date in the future. Futures are widely traded for commodities such as coffee, sugar, oil, and wheat. Futures are also traded for financial instruments such as stock market indexes, government bonds. and foreign currencies. Futures ...Understanding Emissions Trading and Global Warming It goes without saying that there is often an inherent conflict between science and economies. Emission trading is an interesting effort in the global warming arena.Understanding Emissions Trading and Global WarmingIt is a mild understatement to say that global warming is both a controversial and misunderstood field. As the decay o ...FOREX Trading Strategy - 6 Tips to Make Big Profits If you want a successful FOREX trading strategy, you should incorporate the following tips into your existing strategy – you should then become a profitable currency trader. The aim is not to just to make money, but to make big profits consistently.Six Essential FOREX Trading Strategy Tips:1. Get a Method you have Confidence in ...E-currency Exchange Trading If you are reading this article you are probably one of the many people who have spent countless hours searching for unique ways to make money on the internet. Very few people have gone on to succeed and most have failed miserably time and time again.So how are some people succeeding? The answer is quite simple; they are finding a busin ...E-currency Trading Program How to Make Money? You just heard about the E-currency Exchange Program. You hear about people making money with it. You wonder if you can make money with it. Is it too complex? Is it a scam? Could you double your income with it? Read on to find the answers.How soon before I can double my investment? Will I be able to get my money out? Can you really make m ...Can A Credit Card Improve Bad Credit? Can a credit card improve bad credit? Can something inherently bad become something good? However, the consensus of most honest financial advisors is that debt is a disease. An ongoing radio commercial announced that credit card debt is the third largest debt growth area amongst Americans. It states that the average credit card debt is $10,000. ...Biker Business.... With motorcycle gang violence again under scrutiny, it’s worth remembering an ominous warning about a biker blueprint for consolidating and carving up territory amongst the strongest clubs to maximise illicit incomes.The warning was contained in a confidential assessment prepared in New Zealand on the activities of the Bandidos and the Hi ...Trading Psychology: Mistakes in a Trading Environment When it comes to trading, one of the most neglected subjects are those dealing with trading psychology. Most traders spend days, months and even years trying to find the right system. But having a system is just part of the game. Don’t get us wrong, it is very important to have a system that perfectly suits the trader, but it is as important as ...Build Your Own Profitable FOREX Trading System in Five Simple Steps If you want to make big profits, then you should know that the best way is do it for yourself - and not rely on others.Any trader (even a novice) can build a successful FOREX trading system - and this article shows you how to build a profitable system in five simple steps.What Makes a Successful FOREX Trading System?Successf ...Trading Psychology - Adopt the Right Mindset for Big Profits! The fact is the majority of traders lose because they cannot control their emotions. Trading psychology is one of the keys to investment success.A simple fact will illustrate the influence of trading psychology:Why the majority of traders loseThere is one statistic that has remained constant since the beginning of investment ...
| 